Welcome to Nikki's Southern Charm Bakery
Discover the warmth and indulgence of our baked-to-order cookies and custom cakes.
Our Signature Cookies
Classic Chocolate Chip
Golden, chewy, and loaded with rich chocolate chips, our classic recipe brings back sweet Southern memories.
Pecan Sandies
Buttery, crumbly cookies with toasted Georgia pecans, dusted in powdered sugar for a true Southern treat.
Lemon Sugar
Bright, zesty lemon cookies with a delicate glaze, perfect for sunny afternoons and sweet celebrations.
Custom Cakes for All Occasions
Weddings & Anniversaries
Celebrate life’s milestones with a custom cake designed to match your vision and theme, from classic elegance to modern flair.
Birthdays & Celebrations
From whimsical children’s cakes to sophisticated adult designs, we create cakes that make every celebration unforgettable.
Decorator's Choice
Explore our Decorator's Choice for unique and beautifully designed treats.
Let our decorator surprise you with a one-of-a-kind creation, featuring seasonal flavors and artistic designs. Perfect for gifts, parties, or when you want something truly special.
Experience & Trust
With years of experience, we bring trust and excellence to every baked creation.
- Locally owned and operated in Tallahassee
- Over 15 years of baking expertise
- Hundreds of happy customers served
Gallery of Creations
Rustic naked cake topped with fresh berries and edible flowers, perfect for a summer celebration.
Assorted hand-decorated cookies in seasonal shapes, arranged on a wooden tray for a festive display.
Mini cupcakes with vibrant buttercream swirls, displayed on a tiered stand for a playful party touch.
What Our Customers Say
“Nikki’s cookies are the best I’ve ever tasted! Every bite reminds me of home.”
— Sarah M.
“Our wedding cake was stunning and delicious. Nikki made our day extra special.”
— James & Emily
“The Decorator’s Choice was a hit at our party. Beautiful and so tasty!”
— Olivia R.
How to Order
Learn how to request a quote and start your custom order conversation with us.
- Fill out our online quote request form with your event details.
- We’ll contact you to discuss your vision and provide a custom quote.
- Confirm your order and let us handle the rest!
Allergy Disclaimer
Please note: Our baked goods are prepared in a kitchen that handles wheat, dairy, eggs, nuts, and soy. If you have a food allergy, please inform us before placing your order. We take care to avoid cross-contamination but cannot guarantee allergen-free products.